The Associated Recyclers of Wisconsin (AROW) was founded in response to a growing need for collaboration and shared resources among recycling professionals in the state. In 1987, discussions began to form a statewide organization aimed at improving recycling practices. The organization's initial focus was on exchanging ideas and resources in several key areas, including public relations, marketing techniques, advocacy efforts, operational information, and the exploration of new recycling methods like curbside collection. Additionally, AROW sought to create public-private partnerships to secure funding and grants to further these efforts.

In 1988, AROW was officially formed as a membership-based organization, establishing its bylaws, board of directors, and various committees. The group began distributing printed newsletters, giving out awards for outstanding recycling efforts, and contracting for executive director services. AROW also became a member of the National Recycling Coalition, strengthening its ties to national recycling advocacy efforts.

By 1990, AROW had become a formally incorporated organization. Three years later, in 1993, the organization achieved 501(c)(3) nonprofit status from the IRS, solidifying its position as a nonprofit entity dedicated to advancing recycling efforts in Wisconsin. This status allowed the organization to more effectively pursue grants and other funding sources to support its mission.